Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Respectfully, I’m a huge fan of muzzle brakes, and I think the type and design of the brake matter a lot.
Radial brakes are notorious for kicking up dirt, dust, and debris. A well-designed baffle-style brake directs the gases differently and can greatly reduce or eliminate that issue.
Are they loud? Absolutely. But I wear OTTO electronic hearing protection in the field anyway. For me, that’s actually an advantage—I can protect my hearing while still hearing game, conversations, and whispered communication better.
The biggest benefit, though, is recoil and muzzle control. Being able to stay in the scope and watch your shot impact the animal is a huge advantage. It also makes staying on target for a quick humane follow-up shot much easier.
For me, it’s all about stacking as many advantages in my favor as possible.
Just my two cents.